Staredit Network

Bah, you hardly get on.

I can be a judge, but I've never made a sig before. I know what is required, though.
I'd grade on a rubric, like this.
Looks:
Creativity:
Effort:

I think thats all thats needed.

meh kinda

ist more like

Render:
Blending:
Text:

Doesn't that all go into looks?
What if you did that wonderfully, but it was so easy and showed no effort? I think mine is better, though you ARE the pro.

i am not teh pro, i jsut started

those are the keys into making a nice siggy though

but in ur view its more overall style of the sig

Judge should always be done by the people. And to prevent atleast a few mass people saying oh i like that one just becuase. We could ask them to give a reason and if there reason isnt good enough we dont need to count. I dont mind but there should be like 1 person counting and people should be judge. The one counting should also not participate ont he sig contest and should know how to read... Thats all i have to say, i feel like we are having to much judge when about only 5 people are going to join the contest..

You can someone else do it. And get a few entry fee... Btw without 5 judge you get more of the entry fee the same system you did but 1/8 of the entry fee i bet someone out there will do atleast a decent job on it..

Btw i agree that 5 judge dont cut it but we cant get 5 judge and 1 judge wont work also. Also i dont want 5 people who dont know anything about sigs just looking at it and saying oh i like this. So i would just like the people to tell us which one they like better thats all..

btw paying entry fee when there is enough people makes it better for us... no sending it back and fourth 20 min aint much either...

ill join

so is this offically closed yet? jp omfg why dont ppl join lol XD

You should have started your contest after Vizual's. Besides, being able to use any program seems to make this competition too easy for some. I don't feel like joining this one.

i'll join

and also i think it should be 5 judges with a grading rubic, something like:

Blending:
Background:
Render:
Text:
Other Effects:

Average/Overall:

also i think thed eadline should be a week from the point at which we have a sufficient amount of participants, and u can't start your sig until then, sufficient i'd say is between 10 and 15, saying "sweet i can't wait" amount would be 20+

also i think there should be 2 categories, Photoshop and MS Paint, u can enter either one or both but if u enter both u must pay and entrance fee along the lines of 40-80 minerals depending on how many sigs u make per category

anyways ya i'm in, who should i make out the entrance fee to???

u cnat join this, its dead, nerdy left, join mine instead

*sigh* oh well

no thanks, i suck with ms paint

=/ no admission fee, why not? u can try for 3rd place?

now THAT is a lame joke.