Staredit Network

I like how you center the attention of the character, and the background. The vertical text is something wierd to me, and I don't like the character - it has only the head, while body position/pose can be very expressive, and you're not using it. So you're cutting off a lot of potential.

All in all, a very good signature.

Its pretty good. Same as Jammed said about the text. Nice Sig.

7/10

7/10
-text
-empty space on the edges.

I was never good at text.

Lol are you kidding me... .5/10

5/10 for your current that one looks good. and good job on massing c4ds.



.2/10



.4/10
Why does the effect look exactly the same? What are you using? Is it some kind of C4D you are just using to create that effect? Becuase your old sprite sig and that one looks exactly the same.
3/10
your current
1/10

Uh keep working guys. HolySin makes amazing stuff.

ADDITION:


This a joke? Negative space is just horrable, your text are making me barf. You seriously call yourself a graphic artist? But dude its ok, your works are still good compair to everyone here. Espeically DEAD... Who seems to call HolySins work crap when all he can do is copy and page images...

Please when you're making "constructive" critisms, stick to the subject of just rating and
posting your thoughts ON THAT OF THE SIG.
These comments aren't needed.
"Lol are you kidding me..."
"This a joke?"
"You seriously call yourself a graphic artist." People have views on art. I think sig making is an art and I'm maybe proficient at it.
"Espeically DEAD... Who seems to call HolySins work crap when all he can do is copy and paste images..."

I'm not offended at all by these comments by the way. I like critism but only if you can state why... and no doubt you have posted "some" constructive critism.

"good job on massing c4ds."
Hardly... Filters...

I made these awhile back, I had them rated but I forgot what they got so I'm posting them again. =]




On this one, the text is to watermark the sig, don't include it's crappyness into its overall score.

5/10
The top is really dark and the text is hard to read.
i like the fog effect on the bottom though.

5/10
Plain bad text

6/10
Those lines look weird. Plain

Please don't be a complete jerk when critiquing peoples sigs. Who are you to come here and be a jerk to people.

<<Reported your post

Flame I see.

Warn I do.

ROFL! This deserves to be quoted.

Good job on those signatures.They look awsome.

1. Nice Job. A little different. 7/10

2. Ver nice, I like it a lot. 8.5/10 I dont see what you say is wrong with text, looks good.

3. Little too far with the lines. 5/10 but still pretty descent sig.


Rate Please, I just made it today because I was bored of my old one that I had for a while. Wasnt trying to break any records with this one, just making a new look.

Text doesn't fit the rest of the sig, the background doesn't match the rest of the sig, and the render doesn't match the rest of the sig. Looks like 3 different images pasted together. 2/10.

Yea, text looks just bad and the car is totally off topic.

Like I said, not trying to break any records and I just wanted a new look. I like it, it looks nice, Who said that the text and everything has to match.

RATE IT
a new sig... and that nightmaremage is really ruining the whole thread with one post with critisisms beyond what you would call a "objectionate critisism" more like a self-rightous opinion with a very bad habit of breaking or not reading rules
i feel hurt. and he smells

Nicey, I especialy like the text.
7/10

Lithium, that is pretty nice work, I like it. Text is kind of difficult to read, but I know what it says. 7.5/10 Good work. Am I the only one who doesnt know what that is a picture of?

Diablo II necromancer.

Not even close to the D2 Necromancer.
I'm pretty sure he used this render of an 'Undead Lich':
http://uplode.us/up/undeadlich.jpg

I guess since I posted here; rate my current. It's about 3 years old, but one of my favorite.

I like it, despite lack of detail.

Rate Please.



The only problem that I have with this is that the text seems blocky, I wanted it small though, I think this is what makes it blocky. What do you think?

You didn't make any of that signature other than the text. And the text is bad. 0/10.

Yea, right.
Well same thing lol.