Report, edit, etc...Posted by Oo.Jamal.oO on 2006-11-27 at 08:27:26
If Clan Arena doesn't download for you, I have temporarily uploaded it to this site.
Clan Arena vFinal
Clan Arena vFinal
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Dada on 2006-11-27 at 19:01:58
Ok heres attachment for my map.... >.<
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Snipe on 2006-11-28 at 18:05:27
End of today i will close this and they will be rated..
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Shocko on 2006-11-28 at 18:21:18
which maps am i rating? Clan Arena and Jo D 4? is that it?
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Oo.Vic.oO on 2006-11-28 at 19:46:25
ZOMG MAKE ME T3H JUDG3 NAO!!!
nao nao nao nao nao nao nao nao
kkthxbye
nao nao nao nao nao nao nao nao
kkthxbye
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Zeratul_101 on 2006-11-28 at 22:41:14
okay, did some testing with shocko. results are in:
Jo_Defence_4
Fun: 8
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 8.5
Professionalism: 8
Total: 28.5/40
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 1
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 5
Professionalism: 4.5
Total: 14.5/40
Jo_Defence_4
Fun: 8
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 8.5
Professionalism: 8
Total: 28.5/40
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 1
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 5
Professionalism: 4.5
Total: 14.5/40
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Snipe on 2006-11-29 at 00:59:30
wtf... those are nasty. i have seen both maps and they are Defidently not that low at all.. You and shocko and sucky jugdes!!! horrible!! Devlin will bring some light to this.. Secondly.. You and shocko post different rates you don't take the averge you poohead..
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Zeratul_101 on 2006-11-29 at 01:40:29
the most punishing rating for Jo defense is originality, i dunno the rating is worth so much. its low cause its a defense. i gave it +2 cause of the vulture deployment, and another +2 cause of the two-unit spawn(which i really liked 
). when i added up the scores, i thought it was awfully low(cause of criteria). my unaveraged opinion is 34/40.
i stand by my decision on Clan Arena though, at most, it could be tweaked by 2 points, maybe. the balance was absolutely horrible..., unit speed was pretty much the only factor, maybe unit size. i also didn't like how long it could take you to get spells(especially with a HT
). it was also too easy to buy the wrong spell.
ps, fixed a tiny error in scores
). when i added up the scores, i thought it was awfully low(cause of criteria). my unaveraged opinion is 34/40.i stand by my decision on Clan Arena though, at most, it could be tweaked by 2 points, maybe. the balance was absolutely horrible..., unit speed was pretty much the only factor, maybe unit size. i also didn't like how long it could take you to get spells(especially with a HT
). it was also too easy to buy the wrong spell.ps, fixed a tiny error in scores
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Shocko on 2006-11-29 at 07:48:05
Jo_Defence_4
Fun: 8
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 8
Professionalism: 7
Total: 27/40
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 5
Originality: 7
Overall Look: 4
Professionalism: 5
Total: 21/40
wrong snipe, these maps were this bad, we don't suck as judges, we actually played them several times to make sure we wasn't missing anything. There is reasons we rated it what we did, I will explain later -- got to go.
Fun: 8
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 8
Professionalism: 7
Total: 27/40
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 5
Originality: 7
Overall Look: 4
Professionalism: 5
Total: 21/40
wrong snipe, these maps were this bad, we don't suck as judges, we actually played them several times to make sure we wasn't missing anything. There is reasons we rated it what we did, I will explain later -- got to go.
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Oo.Vic.oO on 2006-11-29 at 15:18:20
QUOTE(Zeratul_101 @ Nov 28 2006, 09:41 PM)
okay, did some testing with shocko. results are in:
Jo_Defence_4
Fun: 8
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 8.5
Professionalism: 8
Total: 28.5/40
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 1
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 5
Professionalism: 4.5
Total: 14.5/40
[right][snapback]596481[/snapback][/right]
Jo_Defence_4
Fun: 8
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 8.5
Professionalism: 8
Total: 28.5/40
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 1
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 5
Professionalism: 4.5
Total: 14.5/40
[right][snapback]596481[/snapback][/right]
fun is 1? that would be like a map that crashes at start of the game, i dont think it can go that low. BTW SNIPE LET ME BE A JUDGE ^.^
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Shocko on 2006-11-29 at 15:20:01
QUOTE(Oo.Vic.oO @ Nov 29 2006, 12:18 PM)
fun is 1? that would be like a map that crashes at start of the game, i dont think it can go that low. BTW SNIPE LET ME BE A JUDGE ^.^
[right][snapback]596746[/snapback][/right]
[right][snapback]596746[/snapback][/right]
technically if the map crashed it would be deducted from professionalism and if you couldn't play it -- it would be 0.
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Oo.Vic.oO on 2006-11-29 at 15:28:36
anyways...there are 3 maps submitted...everyone is going to win?
Maps are:
Clan Arena
Jo Defence 4
Terrorist Bound
even though im not a judge i'll rate them anyways ^.^
i'll do that on saturday
Maps are:
Clan Arena
Jo Defence 4
Terrorist Bound
even though im not a judge i'll rate them anyways ^.^
i'll do that on saturday
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Shocko on 2006-11-29 at 15:35:15
i never saw the third map... ill do that in a little while.
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Oo.Jamal.oO on 2006-11-29 at 15:53:51
Ouch, you guys are killing me.. I've played both maps, and these are my opinions..
Jo_Defence_4
Fun: 8 (Was very fun
)
Originality: 4 (Considering that Icy made a map just like it a while ago.. a good rating.)
Overall Look: 7 ( Nice looking Terrain and well made character overlaps n stuff..)
Professionalism: 6.5 (Not saying that it wasn't "professional", it just wasn't a really hard map to do.. it was basically glitch free, just semi-easy..)
Total: 25.5/40
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 4.5 (It's more of an "Experimental" map, but it's still fun to play with full house..)
Originality: 6 (We've had spell maps before, it's really not that original, although the clan idea is..?)
Overall Look: 7 (I thought the terrain was nicely put together, and the overlaps, although not flashy, were okay.)
Professionalism: 8 (Hard map to pull off in my opinion, although half-way through I realized some easier ways to do some of the triggers, but I was too lazy to redo all of them..)
Total: 25.5/40
Alright, those are my personal opinions (No, I didn't add them up so they both equaled 25.5) and i will stick to them. I know it got rated 43/50 by Snipe though, so I'm happy . Anyway, I don't know who should win.. but I don't know if the ratings are fair..
Jo_Defence_4
Fun: 8 (Was very fun
)Originality: 4 (Considering that Icy made a map just like it a while ago.. a good rating.)
Overall Look: 7 ( Nice looking Terrain and well made character overlaps n stuff..)
Professionalism: 6.5 (Not saying that it wasn't "professional", it just wasn't a really hard map to do.. it was basically glitch free, just semi-easy..)
Total: 25.5/40
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 4.5 (It's more of an "Experimental" map, but it's still fun to play with full house..)
Originality: 6 (We've had spell maps before, it's really not that original, although the clan idea is..?)
Overall Look: 7 (I thought the terrain was nicely put together, and the overlaps, although not flashy, were okay.)
Professionalism: 8 (Hard map to pull off in my opinion, although half-way through I realized some easier ways to do some of the triggers, but I was too lazy to redo all of them..)
Total: 25.5/40
Alright, those are my personal opinions (No, I didn't add them up so they both equaled 25.5
) and i will stick to them. I know it got rated 43/50 by Snipe though, so I'm happy . Anyway, I don't know who should win.. but I don't know if the ratings are fair..Report, edit, etc...Posted by Shocko on 2006-11-29 at 16:07:47
Jo_Defence_4
Fun: 8
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 8
Professionalism: 7
Total: 27/40
Fun 8: As fun as defenses get in my opinion.
Originality 4: Not only is this number 4 in the series showing you've made plenty more before it, it's a defense.
Overall Look 8: Terrain wasn't amazing but it was a defense, the overlaps were very nicely put together and looked good.
Professionalism 7: All though the vulture system was creative, it was buggy. MCing the units to upgrade twice was rather annoying, i hated the spammy message for pretty much everything i did.
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 5
Originality: 7
Overall Look: 4
Professionalism: 5
Total: 21/40
Fun 5: The spells were horrible, and the arena was too big.
Originality 7: original idea that you use the clans and members names, however the spells were pretty un original.
Overall Look 4: The terrain wasn't great, the overlaps were okay, however could of used some more, the spells were very poor looking.
Professionalism 5: The spell selection system was so annoying, you had to walk everywhere, the fact that you could purchase spells even when your spell book was full was another thing. The fact i was FORCED to be a clan, which isn't indicated by the forces annoyed me. Let alone the fact that being in a specific clan didn't get me any advantages and we wasn't teammates.
Fun: 8
Originality: 4
Overall Look: 8
Professionalism: 7
Total: 27/40
Fun 8: As fun as defenses get in my opinion.
Originality 4: Not only is this number 4 in the series showing you've made plenty more before it, it's a defense.
Overall Look 8: Terrain wasn't amazing but it was a defense, the overlaps were very nicely put together and looked good.
Professionalism 7: All though the vulture system was creative, it was buggy. MCing the units to upgrade twice was rather annoying, i hated the spammy message for pretty much everything i did.
Clan Arena vFinal
Fun: 5
Originality: 7
Overall Look: 4
Professionalism: 5
Total: 21/40
Fun 5: The spells were horrible, and the arena was too big.
Originality 7: original idea that you use the clans and members names, however the spells were pretty un original.
Overall Look 4: The terrain wasn't great, the overlaps were okay, however could of used some more, the spells were very poor looking.
Professionalism 5: The spell selection system was so annoying, you had to walk everywhere, the fact that you could purchase spells even when your spell book was full was another thing. The fact i was FORCED to be a clan, which isn't indicated by the forces annoyed me. Let alone the fact that being in a specific clan didn't get me any advantages and we wasn't teammates.
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Snipe on 2006-11-29 at 18:29:08
More reasonable.. Zeratul_101 is fired.. Now we need Devlins rate..
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Shocko on 2006-11-29 at 18:30:45
QUOTE(Snipe @ Nov 29 2006, 03:29 PM)
More reasonable.. Zeratul_101 is fired.. Now we need Devlins rate..
[right][snapback]596877[/snapback][/right]
[right][snapback]596877[/snapback][/right]
Zeratul was a little harsh i know, but couldn't you give him a second chance?
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Oo.Jamal.oO on 2006-11-29 at 19:11:56
More just ratings I feel. I know the spells weren't that good, but it took a while to make the map. I feel the ratings could all go up 1, the look 2. I mean, the look, how is it bad? Other than that, kkthxbye
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Shocko on 2006-11-29 at 19:29:19
I'm sorry jamal, it's just what i rated. I still enjoy dodging your kamikaze's <3
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Oo.Jamal.oO on 2006-11-29 at 19:49:24
Yes, I do have bad memories of that...
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Shocko on 2006-11-29 at 19:50:57
QUOTE(Oo.Jamal.oO @ Nov 29 2006, 04:49 PM)
Yes, I do have bad memories of that...
[right][snapback]596942[/snapback][/right]
[right][snapback]596942[/snapback][/right]
bad memories
!?!?!! they were the best, you was getting gg'ed and i wasn't doing anything Report, edit, etc...Posted by Oo.Jamal.oO on 2006-11-29 at 19:57:13
Bad for me.. good for you.
Anywayz, I miss you guys.. I can't even get on East because of temp ban, maybe you'd see me on West sometime if you want to play.. I miss you guys..
Anywayz, I miss you guys.. I can't even get on East because of temp ban, maybe you'd see me on West sometime if you want to play.. I miss you guys..
Report, edit, etc...Posted by DevliN on 2006-11-30 at 19:29:59
- Clan Arena vFinal
- Fun: 5
- Originality: 6
- Overall Look: 6
- Professionalism: 7
- Jo Defense 4
- Fun: 7
- Originality: 5
- Overall Look: 8
- Professionalism: 7
Obviously I'm a sucker for defenses.
Sorry for the late scores. I got called into work early this morning to cover a friend's shift.
Report, edit, etc...Posted by Snipe on 2006-12-02 at 18:09:59
ty devlin.. if hydra could get to adding up the scores...i will give the minerals.. i have no time to atm.. because time is limited on this comp.. I will be back later maybe..