QUOTE(Snake)Ling @ May 13 2006, 07:30 AM)
Foolhardy idiot, you say we wish to kill you, we call you swine, we wish to fight you. Some flaws in your argument:
[-] There are several vastly different versions of the Qu'ran. Some versions have been produced as propoganda devices by terrorist groups such as Al-Quaeda.
I understand that, and I'm not disregarding that. The site to which I linked did a little argument on the propaganda, but I was running low on time when I got to that point, so I didn't include it. I guess I'll get the key points out of it now:
Muslims living in Western democracies (such as the US and Europe) try to defend their religion by quoting Surats 2:256 which says, “There is no compulsion in religion.” That means that they should not react without thinking any and all the actions out.
This is a peaceful verse, but it's been abrogated later in the book. This verse, of course, was written before Muhammed was persecuted by the Christians and the Jews
(I'm assuming that you're right on the Sura/Surats spelling)
- Some believe it was abrogated Surats 9:73, which says, “O Prophet, struggle with the unbelievers and hypocrites, and be harsh with them.” says to be unfriendly with disbelievers.
- Another group of Islamic clerics accepts the words to mean what they say, but they argue that they were part of Allah’s strategy to advance Islam. While Muslims were weak, Allah spoke through Muhammad and told them to tolerate infidels. But when the Muslims became strong, Allah commanded them to cease being tolerant and attack and subdue the infidels.
Bottom line, it says to at least be unfriendly to 'infidels', and some extremists take that far (and I know extremists don't represent a religion) and start killing in the name of Allah.
QUOTE
[-] You failed to directly quote the Surats (correct spelling). The way we believe God is is that he does not forgive murder, rape, or pillage. Thus, the basis of your argument cannot be accepted.
I gave the verses. It would take too long to quote all the verses, however, there are online versions of the book, no? (http://www.muslim.org/english-quran/quran.htm for those too lazy to google).
QUOTE
[-] You failed to mention the Crusades, which were done in the name of Jesus, Christian God and Christianity. You say we wish to kill you, yet you go on massive slaughters, killing even people who have surrendered.
The crusades were an aberration in Christian history based upon perverted Catholic doctrine and not upon any biblical injunction. In contrast, the intolerance and violence that have characterized Islam throughout its history are firmly rooted in the Koran.
QUOTE
[-] You fail to mention the Spanish Inquisition, done for the same reasons, yet in a slower, more painful manner against BOTH JEWS AND MUSLIMS.
This, I do not know of, but Spain is a Catholic nation. I am not Catholic as I believe it's a abberation of the Christian faith.
QUOTE
[-] You fail to mention that the ISLAMIC EMPIRE ACCEPTED JEWISH PEOPLE AS MINISTERS AND NORMAL CITIZENS.
Where, when?
QUOTE
[-] You said giving charity to the poor is at odds with the bible. Why should I believe in an uncharitous religion? Charity is a central part of my life, I give money to make a feast for poor Indonesian children, yearly.
The bible does not say "Do not give charity". It says to be kind to the poor, take them in and feed them. Be kind to the sick, take them in and feed them.
QUOTE
[-] We believe God judges all. He does not forgive anyone for murdering or raping, as you do in Christianity.
Becuase our God is a merciful, graceful God. If you
are truly sorry, he'll forgive you. But if you aren't repentant, he wont. It's not a case of "Oh, you raped someone. I'll just ignore that because you're Christian"
QUOTE
[-] We, at least in New English mosques, believe that God will allow anyone who was a good person in life, regardless of religion, into Heaven.
This is another point that separates our religions. Your religion is that of works. You do good, you will go to heaven. With Christianity, noone can bypass Jesus and get to Heaven.
QUOTE
[-] Jesus was not, in fact, the son of God. He was a very good prophet of God.
Another point from which we differ. To me, Jesus was the Christ, the Son of God, as well as God. Our whole faith is based on this.
QUOTE
[-] There is only one God, and that is Allah. "Islam" literally translates to "unconditional surrender (to God).
I believe that there is only one God, in three parts. Father (Yahweh), Son (Christ), and Holy Spirit.
QUOTE
[-] Allah is, infact, not knowable to us. We find this to be a fact as prayers are not answered in a direct, straightforward fashion. We find this to be a fact as God has not appeared on Earth.
But, you see, Christians believe that he
has come to earth.
QUOTE
So, we believe in the same God as you, but not in the same fashion.
Then it's not the same God.
QUOTE
I think God would not like Christians and Muslims to feud, but you do. You're not a good Christian, like the folks I know.
I know for a fact that I'm not a good representation of a Christian. I don't do what's right all the time, I curse God's name a lot.
QUOTE
Why can't you just accept peace with Muslims?
Just for the record, I'm in no way saying that Muslims should die.
QUOTE
Some Muslim countries are even more liberal and open-minded than Christian countries. Indonesia, which has the largest Muslim population in the world, has had a women president, and America hasn't.
They're 100% allowed to run, just none have run nor won.
QUOTE
And, for the hammerblow:
If God loves all humanity so as you say, Kow, why do you throw hatred at me? Isn't that at odds with your own view of God? You call Muslims contradictory fellows, yet you openly try to convert me by implying my religion is a religion of hate and stupidity. You'll probably go to Heaven for worshipping God so zealously in your own ways, but be in your own bounds.
It's not the zealousness of my worship that gets me into heaven. I'm not meaning, if I show that I am, to hate you. I am human.
QUOTE
Finally, I think I know much more about what I believe in than you know. Don't quote the Qu'ran to me, I don't blindly follow the Qu'ran like a sheep. Accept it, I am Islamic, you are Christian. You're not going to change that, in fact, you're making me dislike Christianity as a whole now.
[right][snapback]485507[/snapback][/right]
I don't see why, from this or from one person, unless everyone of that religion says that he/she's representing that religion, that people dislike religions.