QUOTE
Have you met him --or her-- CheeZe?
I don't need to. You made the claim:
QUOTE
He is useless to me and has no purpose.
I ask you to prove it.
QUOTE
Do you believe that god exists? If so why?
Did you read
anything I wrote? I specifically said I was agnostic.
QUOTE
What claim am I making? I don't believe in their claim, that's not a claim.
...
I'm not asserting "truth", I am not making a "claim" towards the nonexistence of God, I deny the truth of another statement.
I am also rejecting that statement. I also reject Min's (which is essentially the same as yours I believe) statement:
QUOTE
I will say that in my opinion there are no gods which is the same thing as saying "I don't believe in any gods".
Thus, you have made a claim and I want you to support it. Despite what you may think, there are three sides. Those who accept the god's existance, those who don't, and those who choose neither.
You're one of those who has made a choice already. You're on the absolute side; you have an opposite. If you're on the opposite of theism, you must have also made a claim.
QUOTE
I have no proof, but you cannot prove me wrong. You see how stupid such logic is?
There are just as many plausable explanations as a god. How come you chose 1 god, and not 2? or 3?.
If it's so plausible, why do you choose to deny the existance of god entirely? Why not accept that there is a
possibility?
QUOTE
According to your logic, any nutcase can come out of the woodworks, make a stupid claim, and you can't "disprove it", despite that not being proper procedure of logical conjecture.
I'm not saying you can disprove their claim. I'm asking you to prove your claim. For the last time, I am not asking you to accept the existance of god. I don't accept it. Nor do I deny it. I only want you to give me reasons why you're atheist.
If the only reason you are is because another
religion (not god) doesn't make sense, then that's not logical at all as it only assumes that there are two possibilities. Why does a god have to be religious at all?
It seems MillenniumArmy is the only one who understands my position. If he understands it, you guys should too. I was afraid I provided to little logic in my post; but since he got it, I know now that I provided enough.
Choerdius: You're still focused on religion. If religion is the only reason you're atheist, refer to the argument above. (Starts with "If the only...")
DeadlyInnocence: Of course I ignored it. It's irrelevant. I don't care about religion. Refer to the above.