With this poll I am going to make a map. Expect more polls in the future!
flaming_X:

Starcraft misses nice movie maps!! hehe. If you have any sense of humor, I'm sure you can build something decent and fun! If your not very strong on movies, though, I'd say a defence//offense map involving melee

And this topic perfectly fits in a mapping forum, not in this dirty, meaningless and spammy place which is the Garbage forum =P
Moved to Staredit General ForumBTW, welcome here! Make a topic in the newbie forum if you desire to be welcomed like you deserve to.
What we need is a good solid fun RPG map that is enjoyable for all!
To me? None of 'em, because they're very common these days. Unless you do something really unique (like Sabatoge Defense, which only a few people have).
Personally, I'd like to see a map where both squadwork and teamwok is involved, like "Team Arena Micro". I tend to like maps that need people to co-operate, which tends to better the StarCraft community due to the relationships that springs from such maps.
I like any map that invovled team work, Lot of fun, can last hours.
Those are main 3 i like about maps, But then again i play any map.
My suggestion...:
Mini-Game map. Tons of tactical/teamworking mini-games, such as Squad Force, in which you builda force of units to get past your enemy teams' defence. That would encourage teamwork, 'cause you'd only get a couple units, and you'd be severely outnumbered by your enemy, so it also encourages spell using, balanced forces, micro-managemant.
Another could be Building Assault, in which you get respawning Probes and Drones, along with buildable Siege Tanks(+Siege Mode), Corsairs, Photon Cannons(+Pylons), Sunkens and Spores, and you have to try to control the whole battle field. And another mini-game in which you make mazes. And all kinds of crap!