
well this is an odd question of course but...Do you think this plot is a good one for a map I'm making?
Ok here it is, You are trapped on an island,no food,anything except your clothing,will you survive,find resources build signs and anything will happen in this island of death...
You're basically marooned after a horrible plane crash that kills the president and everyone else on that plane...
You like it?

I'm Glad they have there clothing. We wouldn't want a bunch of naked people running around on this island.
Sounds like a cool idea but just like everything it depends on how it is put together, the idea only plays a small role in my opionion.
Aww c'mon naked people are fun!! That would spread the map's popularity though...

btw dammit Phantasy you stole my icon!!!

Lets not start on naked maps again (cough pleasure maps cough).
Bolt Head is right to a degree. Its how you make it. However, the idea does play a role as well. Its fun to make maps that have never been dont with new features. Honestly, you like playing sunken D over and over? Or do you get sick and tired of it?
Possibly a piece of ****, possibly an awesome map. It all depends on what options, what you do, and all that fun stuff!
Most likely a bit to the **** side, if you were to make it, though.
thanks for the encouraging -.-
You could say add new stuff... But then you notice people play the same maps on bnet every single day... It is all summed in this phrase: "bnet's IQ < my foot". Honestly, I think you have a good idea, just don't make it too complicating otherwise people will get confused. "simplicity > complexity" is bnet's motto.