I want to know what everyone thinks about this

maybe because I'm a nerd

i just want to get statistics, thanks.
Oh, and me, I vote Broodwar.

Brood War.
Im stuck on Diablo 2, because i started the game out on single player, and im at a part I just cant get past. Now your probably thinking on multiplayer I could, but since I started on single Player, I dont want to start Diablo 2 all over again. I am like... level 30...
Damnit, if I could I would pick both but I can't so...
It would have to be Diablo 2, It has a better story and it's more realistic than Starcraft (not sounding idiotic, but I'm more of realistic player.)
Broodwar DEFINATELY
Diablo seems to steal all of my friends away from me...like 15 in the past have left Broodwar for it and never come back.
Sidenote: I have never played Diablo...(HEHEHE GO BROODWAR)
Diablo sucks ass. Broodwar is faster, deeper, and more refined. Plus, it is more competitive, and there are tons more players. And there is no Diablo pro scene!
Both are good games, but I'd have to say BW. Diablo just gets boring after a while. It's all the same things just looking for items, and trading and stuff. With SC it's not always the same thing because each game is different. But I guess both games are different types of games.
I agree with ihatett on how it's faster/deeper/competitive.
I can't even play Diablo II for 5 minutes alone without getting insanly bored. BroodWar > Diablo II always. In Diablo II with a couple friends it's not as boring, but still doesn't beat Diablo I.
BroodWar is just my all time favorite game.
Hmm starcraft site...hmm...I think I will say that Broodwar is Better than Diablo II. I own Starcraft Broodwar, don't own Diablo II. I like RTS better and I only played Diablo for a bit although it is still fun Starcraft is better.
Diablo 2 is a joke compared to BW...
I'm not sure how Diablo II is more realistic than Starcraft, they are both pretty unrealistic games. But Both games are fun. I like the trading Aspect of Diablo, and I also like the more large scale fighting in BroodWar.
I think starcraft brood is better, because I haven't really played diablo a long time (only up to lv 10 bcause I was playing at my friends house) and, I like strategic games better than RPGs (sometimes).
grrr diablo pisses me off...i had an awsome account with good items but I didnt play for a month n it deleted my account....
STARCRAFT!
Yea i hate the way Diablo is set up so ill have to go with
BroodWar

Hmmmm.... let's see... Broodwar! And also this is an SC site so everyone here would probably say Broodwar.
Okay, I used to be a total Diablo nerd, before I discovered SC. Okay this is what you do in d2, you play 5 different acts, when you finish, you play them again, and then again till you finish and then you level yer anus off till you hit 99, then you're totally rich, and have the highest level possible aaaaaaand....now what? Starcraft has not ever gotten bored for the past 5 years I've played it. I started lots of other games, but I always came back to SC because it gets new everytime I do, new maps man, thats what really matters.
By the way, for the help on the level 30 guy. Rip someone off to give you a full run of the game for like 5 sojs then don't even give em. And ta-da by then you're 75.
Diablo =

reach lvl 99....thats almost impossible without a mf bot
QUOTE
and have the highest level possible aaaaaaand....now what?
Then u go n kill all the noobs and steal their money n their ears

Hell yeah. But true, it does get boring after a while. Thats why I like both SC and D2 (More D2

)
omg!! some1 likes d2 moree!! Ban!! j/k
Thats why I played world of warcraft for only 3-4 months. I hit level 49. Now, it's really easy to level in that game IF YOUR PATIENT. I am the most impatient little bastard you'll ever meet. So now, I can go gank noobs, or I can go try to level and get killed by some level 60 punk. Isn't it the same in d2?
That's another reason why any game with the word Warcraft in it sucks. I hope blizzard learned their lesson already and will now continue their work in the starcraft world.
Both games are pretty fun. But overall, I would prefer BroodWar.
BroodWar is much funner, You can actually inflitrate other bases, And make your own map's, Where Diablo cannot.
yeah i waste my money buyin warcraft 3 n expansion when i stopped playin in a week(at least i got cd key)
DiabloII betrayed me.. i had everything.. level 99 sorc.. i owned at duels.. Ultra equipment... i was looking for more sojs to give to my other account.. showed the person everything i had... if he wants to trade anything for a soj (stone of jordan ring)..... then i clicked ok by accident.. he got all my equipment for free...
i stopped diablo after that.. nothing lik that happened in BW

brood waris better in my opinion

This is good, I think we have all conceded that Broodwar is better for many reasons. But many idiots out there do not have the brain power to realize their foolish mistakes (into playing retarded games like WCIII and such)
Yea, brood war can't screw you over like that

If only BW had a ladder as updated as D2 then it would be much better, meh but no one players ladder anywa, I guess people are used to it.