tell me what u think. 1-10 scale if ya want. its my first ps pic
Could use different font? Alright wirlpool twist so i give it a 5 of 10.
It's simple, and it works...to a point. You need a better font. I give it a 6.5 out of 10.
4/10
those types of pictures don't appeal to me as it is, and yours is far too simple for my taste
OK, the average rating as of now is 5.16 out of 10.
i like the grayness but the font isnt that awesome, if the font was different then it would have a higher rate, 4.7/10
Addition: Average = 5.05/10
Sheese, you guys adding this up? Brood, i think @:@ has lots of PS Fonts.
Umm..yeah...that is a good filter. twirl.
and yeah, im a font addicted,
"Gotta have 'em all!"
lol....
i have kinda alot
but u know i dont really like it its kinda just.... simple. i mean it has no specail effects at all.... exept the twirl lol...
2.6
Average rating as of right now: 4.56 out of 10.
sen hates me and isnt uploading the new one. ifound a sweet font too
ADDITION: there got it wewt!!
U guys are mean, its his first, i give it a 7, keep practicing
4.5/10 I don't really like it. If the whirlpool had maybe a little bit of something else I would think it would be better.
But still gotta love the whirlpool effect.
6.5/10. It's better than what I can do and I think it's missing something, it's like sort of simple...
ty for feedback, im tryin out new stuff btw the lens flare is a sun gettin pwned by a black hole
Personally, I'd made the sig wider... I don't quite see the point of it right now...
I give it like a 5.5 or a 6. Its not that bad for your first but i think you can do better.
I'd give the first sig a 5 for being too small

.
Lets also rate the sig above our post (isn't that what usually happens in these topics?)!
I give Chill's a 7/10 - I like the font and the text (heh) but the background is a simple Render>Clouds filter on PS.
My sig is my first attempt at a sig involving my name...
yes im working on a wider one
Oh we should start a rate the above users sig thread!
BTW hows this?
its still simplr than mine

looks good though
The new sig you posted is better. It has a better background and a betetr feeling to it.
Average rating as of now: 5.38 out of 10 or 5.33 out of 10, depending on Chill's vote.
UPDATE: The average is now 5.38 out of 10.
I just read a review of halo2 so i feel like being generous. You sir, get a 6.