As most as you know my new editor is going to be called ScmStudio and the DLL ScmLib. Now that I cracked the full .rep format I ask this to the map making comunity. Replays might be good for make a movie map

make it so you can edit anything. more options are always better

Clokr_, I can't support something that could be used as cheating in melee tournaments. You have to make it mark somehow that its not a real replay.
As a victim, I say make it be marked as fake.

How would this work though clokr? Triggers in a replay? Explain it plainly.
What do you mean exactly? That it can crack replays and place them into your map, or that you can create a perfect UMS movie of what you are doing and allow it as the movie map?
You would be able to create and edit replays. I think that you would have to designate all actions and events happening in the replay.
Mark altered replays! That's what you should focus on. Make sure that they're not easily changed back into regular replays.
Maybe is way put at start of the replay text that says, " This is a Edited / Fake reproduction replay " or something =/
I'm tired, but I say the last one;
just don't mess with them.
Maybe just stamp a little image in the top right corner or something that says Produced By ScmStudio. I'm sure there's some way. Also, ScmStudio? Are you gonna make an expansion and call it ScxStudio?

isnt this replay in the wrong forum? w/e i think replays shouldnt b messed wit
Actually why not make it require another program to run correctly, either running in the background of starcraft or just an edit version of it. Though that would annoy those using it for movie maps...
why would u call a .rep editor ScmStudio?
i think the edited replays should be marked.. maybe it could just be in the hex somewhere that ppl wouldnt find and then you could have a original .rep validator function on your program aswell
Let it be able to edit anything. More options=better. If all everyone was afraid to edit starcraft stuff, we would all still be using Staredit for all of our maps.
QUOTE
As a victim, I say make it be marked as fake.
I third the motion
OMFG it would be so cool if we could mak eour own replays. make it so we can do ANYTHING!!!!!!!! open old ones and change them, or make new ones from maps. BUUUUUUTTTTTTTT!!!!!! make it so no matter what you do, it marks it as fake somehow. like maby a little message at the top: ScmStudio Production
Make it be able to edit replays. The more options we have, the better.
I was wrong, you would have to mark them as fake some how Clokr, not doing so is too dangerous.
Until someone find a way to erase the "Fake Replay" sign.... That could be interesting for movie yes... but... If it's going into wrong hand... i don't want to see what will happen *Echo*
Editing replays might be a good way to make movies if its easier to do than making a movie with a map. But it could be used to edit a melee game replay, so it needs to be marked as a edited replay.
Can you show text in a replay? If so that would be the best way to mark it as a edited replay. (start the replay off with some text and a wait)
Would you be able to protect your replay/movie?
Actually just like Protection it would be only a matter of time till someone broke the "Fake Reply Add-On" Feature and removed it, but then again, would there be the market for it? A person would only do that on a widescale if he/she knew that a large percentage, or amount of the community wanted it.
Unprotecting maps for Starcraft is popular, will these replays be? I am not soo sure...
LOL protected replays so BWChART cannot open it

I would like my edited replayed to be played by BWchart.
That way I could edit my strategies and see If I could've won.
Anyways always mark the new edited replay with a [ER] at the end so that way you know it's an edited replay.
Make it so that the [ER] can't be removed or changed.
Do replays even have sound and text?