QUOTE
No, its fact that there are terrorists in the prison. The burden of proof is on you becuase your statement was an assumption saying that most are not terrorists.
All right, I'll even let you have the fact that there are terrorists. Nevertheless, the burden of proof is still on you to prove the other detainees are terrorists as well.
QUOTE
Your also trying to apply American laws on people who aren't American. Thats like saying I can drink beer at 16 becuase some European country's allow that, so I apply their laws over mine.
Why would you deny human beings their basic rights? Isn't it morally wrong to detain a person that has not been charged with anything? I'm not talking about a person who has had dealings with terrorists, I'm talking about a person who has absolutely no relationship with anything that want to live out normal lives.
There are normal people who have clear records at Guantanamo. You can't possibly tell me that it's morally ok to keep them.
How do I know there are normal people? Research:
http://www.upi.com/NewsTrack/view.php?Stor...13-095958-4072rFor more:
http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ned=us&i...tnG=Search+NewsQUOTE
And if I was detained I would know exactly why disgust.gif You would have to go to great lengths to be arrested as a terrorist.
Apparantly not, as shown by above. Five muslims were detained for fours years without a charge. Now they have no where to go.
QUOTE
And my logic is based upon what people have ALREADY done, not what they COULD do, don't think you know what my logic is.
Oh good, you agree with me then. A trial would be perfect. It would separate those who have done something and those who have not.
QUOTE
Cheeze, they probably should have a trial, but I don't see how that would fix anything, to even convince a person to testify, even if anonymously, there is rapid fear. I just see a trial as a way for guilty men to be set free and giving them what they want.
Are you have doubts about the American courts system?
If so, then I don't see how can you even trust the Bush administration.
If not, then why do you sound like you don't trust the courts to judge upon these detainees?
QUOTE
You could if person A was likely to shoot you next or your trying to save your friend.
No, you still don't have the
legal rights. However, under the circumstances, if you were to go to court, it would be extremely difficult in finding you to be guilty.