I said 'doodads' because many people can make them. I said Ice, because their in ice terrain. Rate Please. Id give myself a 6/10 for ideas, but there is some blockiness.

I like the first one, the second one has a little blockyness, but it still looks somewhat good.
Only the left one is a 'Doodad', and for the left im going to give a 3/10 because ALL that is--is an Ice ramp going onto cliffs, nothing special.
as for the right one that isnt a doodad. thats just Outpost Terrain put together, 4/10
I have not seen that ice/cliff ramp before. I like it!
QUOTE(Chronophobia @ May 1 2006, 09:43 AM)
I have not seen that ice/cliff ramp before. I like it!
[right][snapback]477067[/snapback][/right]
Me neither
The first one is a good one but the second one indeed is blocky, and anyways you should be able to fix it

First one:
6/10, but 9/10 for usefulness.
secondone 2/10. Eek. It sucks.
5/10 on first there is definate blockyness
6/10 on second one. at a glance its not blocky but in game it will be
QUOTE(A_of_s_t @ Apr 30 2006, 11:25 PM)
I said 'doodads' because many people can make them. I said Ice, because their in ice terrain. Rate Please. Id give myself a 6/10 for ideas, but there is some blockiness.

[right][snapback]476945[/snapback][/right]
Better than i could ever do

Well... anyway... gj! 6/10 1st... 5/10 2nd.. (teh blockzeyness!!

)
I made a few more, the double story building is improved, but, I'll send it in a little later

...I like it!
The 2nd one reminds me of what my friend did in one of his maps but he kind of over did it.
The first one is absolutely BEAUTIFUL. And I give much props for you not doing jungle.
1st - All you need to do is fix the cliffs a tad, 9/10.
2nd - Well, it's super useful, and looks really good if you don't over analyze it. But when you do you see blockiness and repiditiveness. 6/10
Fix them, keep terraining, make a sensual ice map.
I really like the 1st one just like alot of people it looks really well done. As for the 2nd one I think it could use a little work but it wouldnt be bad just to use it that way eather its like 50/50 good and bad
1st one: 9/10
2nd: 5/10
Doodad Update:
[attachmentid=18610]
Rate please.
QUOTE(A_of_s_t @ May 1 2006, 10:19 PM)
Doodad Update:
[attachmentid=18610]
Rate please.
[right][snapback]477682[/snapback][/right]
Okay, the one up to the left, it isn't really appealing, because that thing with the extended structures like that only makes it blocky.
The one top to the right is not flowing natural, you should use two different sets of terrain than just that, because if you have them on a line it will look repetive, and noone wants it repetive.
The bridge is well done, but it isn't walkable, therefore it's unneccessary to even make, also it's unoriginal.
top left one looks like you purposely made it big and people cant tell. blocky

but you can try to find better tiles above the blocky ones that would make it a little less blocky. 6/10
the top right is nearly perfect.

it's just you can see weird colors in the snow. like on some parts of the level 2 base. try to fix those so they match the rest of the ledge 8/10
the bottom is flawless. i think bridge work in any titleist is easy to pull off so ill give you a 9/10

gj
The changed extended structure looks worse than original. Sorry.
lol, the bridge is walkable ( in the editor, I cant check in SC, my comp will crash... )
The reason the jungle and badlands bridges are so much easier to modify around is because they essentially use the same tile over and over. The others kind of have a preset "gradient"-ish thing going on. The metal walls are bad. Sorry bud, but it's true. The ice ramp is awesome, but has some rough spots Where the ramp goings into the cliff on the left and when it goes to the ice wall on the right. If that can't be fixed... well, there's always sprites. The Brood War tilesets are generally harder to work with. The snow to snow blend looks nice, but what does it look like in practice, (ie, a full wall)? Not so good? It looks nice otherwise. The bridge is sexy, though a few bridge tiles don't blend into the edges, it's probably the best you're gonna get it. I'll have to check out Ice a bit.
the height of the bridge compared to the ground makes it look paradoxal
snow cliff looks cool
i know how u feel on the metal cliff

The bridge seems to narrow, almost doesn't look walkable. and its nothing new
5/10
Hmm, I did that kind of bridge before, but compared to other tilesets I actually haven't spent a lot of time with Ice. Ice does have good options to work with, though (structure, nature, ice/snow, and water all in one).
I did some Ice terrain cliff research a while back... here is what I gathered. I am tired of keeping stuff like this just for my own amusement.
[attachmentid=18642]
Yeah show me up... lol, ill dl it later, I have to go...
ADDITION:
Those were okay blends. Some of them were plain though. The whole map, I'd rate 9/10 since I saw some pretty good things.