In no particular order...
1: I like where the text is, the fonts used, their sizes, etc., +2
2: It's compact, +4
3: Pretty, but not excessive, use of blues and grays, +6
4: I don't know why... but I like grid lines... +1
A: If the main area(as in, the space that is not border, lol) has any particular picture in it, I can't tell what it is, -1
B: Border seems too... lumpy... -2
C: What's that on the top right? -1
So, overall: (2+4+6+1)-(1+2+1)= 9
- - - - - - - - - - 13 - - - - - 4 - - - Pwnt?